• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

TOWERS

Austin city life since 2007

  • News
    • Condo Projects
    • Neighborhoods
  • Listings
    • Austin Condo Guide
  • Newsletter
  • Realty
Search
You are here: Home / News / The Trump Administration Thinks This Austin Courthouse Is Really Ugly
Search suggestions: condos for sale • rainey street

The Trump Administration Thinks This Austin Courthouse Is Really Ugly

James Rambin February 5, 2020 Comment

A view of the federal courthouse in downtown Austin from West Fifth and San Antonio Streets. Image: Page

A draft executive order from the White House outlining a rewrite of national guidelines for federal architecture cites downtown Austin’s U.S. courthouse facility as an example of a government building with “little aesthetic appeal.” Good heavens!

A view of the building from West Fourth Street. Image: Mack Scogin Merrill Elam Architects

The draft order, titled “Making Federal Buildings Beautiful Again,” would hugely shape the design of future federal structures by demanding adherence to a “classical architectural style” over more modern designs — and Austin’s courthouse, along with the San Francisco Federal Building and Miami’s own federal courthouse, is among the three specific examples the order cites as failures to provide “visual testimony to the dignity, enterprise, vigor, and stability of the American government.”

The draft decries the quality of architecture under the General Service Administration’s (GSA) Design Excellence Program for its failure to re-integrate “our national values into Federal buildings” which too often have been “influenced by Brutalism and Deconstructivism.”

— Architectural Record, February 4, 2020

A view of the building’s backside at West Fourth and Nueces Streets. Image: AIA Austin / Casey Dunn

The courthouse, opened at the former site of downtown’s infamous Intel shell at 501 West Fifth Street in 2012, features design from Atlanta architects Mack Scogin Merrill Elam and local firm Page. It’s directly adjacent to the historic Republic Square park.

A clipping of an article discussing the preliminary courthouse plan including renderings of its design from the March 28, 2006 edition of the Austin-American Statesman. Image: Austin History Center

In 2016, the facility received an award from the Justice Facilities Review of the American Institute of Architects (AIA), and the jury had lots of superlatives on hand:

The jury found this project to be a finely crafted instrument, unapologetically modern, appropriately conveying the dignity of the institution. The connection to the heavily used public plaza is so important, and the building entry and lobby serve very effectively as extensions and enhancements to the public space. Clearly a mature expression, this reinterpretation of the judiciary manifests itself as grounded in its place, simultaneously exuberant yet modest, even restrained, spatially and functionally complex, subtle and consummately graceful in its detail, thorough and fittingly attentive throughout.

The well-proportioned, asymmetrical courtrooms seem to rest comfortably balanced between formality and wit. Much of the richness seems to be communicated directly through the well-choreographed palette of materials that expresses appropriateness and longevity through fine workmanship—an exemplary project in every aspect.

— AIA 2016 Justice Facilities Review

It would be hard to tell an architect you don’t like their building more succinctly than by arguing its very existence creates a precedent for prohibiting future designs of its nature on a federal level, but we don’t really think Austin’s courthouse deserves quite this much hate. The only complaints we’ve heard regarding its design relate to the security requirements of a federal building harming its accessibility at the pedestrian scale, and you can blame Timothy McVeigh for that, not postmodern architecture.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by tommydugan (@tommydugan)

In response to reports on the draft, the AIA issued this statement via tweet:

The AIA strongly opposes uniform style mandates for federal architecture. Architecture should be designed for the specific communities that it serves, reflecting our rich nation’s diverse places, thought, culture and climates. Architects are committed to honoring our past as well as reflecting our future progress, protecting the freedom of thought and expression that are essential to democracy.

Eric Rauser, the 2020 president of Austin’s AIA chapter, also provided a statement:

Advocating for or against any stated style of architecture both undermines and demonstrates a lack of understanding of architectural design. Buildings must be designed to respond to the natural and cultural context in which they reside. The U.S. Courthouse in Austin embodies the values of the current Guiding Principles for Federal Architecture as well as reflects the values of our city in many ways including its embrace of public space and regional materials. AIA Austin is gratified by the virtues embodied this building and the work of all our membership.

Latest Downtown Austin Condos For Sale

  • $5,150,000 70 Rainey ST #3203
    Austin, TX
  • $579,000 360 Nueces ST #1318
    Austin, TX
  • $535,000 54 Rainey ST #910
    Austin, TX
  • $1,090,000 84 East Ave #1509
    Austin, TX
  • $838,000 84 East Ave #2404
    Austin, TX
  • $625,000 1801 Lavaca ST #13G
    Austin, TX
  • $2,995,000 210 LAVACA St #2610
    Austin, TX
  • $740,000 48 East Ave #2004
    Austin, TX
  • $4,500,000 202 Nueces ST #2702
    Austin, TX
  • $549,000 360 Nueces ST #3006
    Austin, TX
  • $799,000 603 Davis ST #902
    Austin, TX
  • $470,000 601 E Brushy ST #204
    Austin, TX
  • $400,000 710 Colorado ST #9F
    Austin, TX
  • $799,000 44 East Ave #3806
    Austin, TX
  • $675,000 360 Nueces ST #1601
    Austin, TX
70 Rainey ST #3203
Austin, TX
Photo of 70 Rainey ST #3203, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 3273694)
$5,150,000
Lot Size
N/A

Home Size
3,685 sqft

Beds
3 Beds

Baths
4 Baths

360 Nueces ST #1318
Austin, TX
Photo of 360 Nueces ST #1318, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 1267741)
$579,000
Lot Size
101 sqft

Home Size
760 sqft

Beds
1 Bed

Baths
1 Bath

54 Rainey ST #910
Austin, TX
Photo of 54 Rainey ST #910, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 8511392)
$535,000
Lot Size
192 sqft

Home Size
756 sqft

Beds
1 Bed

Baths
1 Bath

84 East Ave #1509
Austin, TX
Photo of 84 East Ave #1509, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 1313525)
$1,090,000
Lot Size
17,163 sqft

Home Size
1,176 sqft

Beds
2 Beds

Baths
2 Baths

84 East Ave #2404
Austin, TX
Photo of 84 East Ave #2404, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 8487174)
$838,000
Lot Size
17,154 sqft

Home Size
892 sqft

Beds
1 Bed

Baths
1 Bath

1801 Lavaca ST #13G
Austin, TX
Photo of 1801 Lavaca ST #13G, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 3315746)
$625,000
Lot Size
353 sqft

Home Size
1,377 sqft

Beds
2 Beds

Baths
2 Baths

210 LAVACA St #2610
Austin, TX
Photo of 210 LAVACA St #2610, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 8572231)
$2,995,000
Lot Size
6,321 sqft

Home Size
2,846 sqft

Beds
4 Beds

Baths
4 Baths

48 East Ave #2004
Austin, TX
Photo of 48 East Ave #2004, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 3776814)
$740,000
Lot Size
N/A

Home Size
893 sqft

Beds
1 Bed

Baths
1 Bath

202 Nueces ST #2702
Austin, TX
Photo of 202 Nueces ST #2702, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 6197965)
$4,500,000
Lot Size
N/A

Home Size
2,570 sqft

Beds
3 Beds

Baths
3.5 Baths

360 Nueces ST #3006
Austin, TX
Photo of 360 Nueces ST #3006, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 2593926)
$549,000
Lot Size
101 sqft

Home Size
748 sqft

Beds
1 Bed

Baths
1 Bath

603 Davis ST #902
Austin, TX
Photo of 603 Davis ST #902, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 5767894)
$799,000
Lot Size
301 sqft

Home Size
1,597 sqft

Beds
2 Beds

Baths
2 Baths

601 E Brushy ST #204
Austin, TX
Photo of 601 E Brushy ST #204, Austin, TX 78702 (MLS # 8694737)
$470,000
Lot Size
567 sqft

Home Size
701 sqft

Beds
1 Bed

Baths
1 Bath

710 Colorado ST #9F
Austin, TX
Photo of 710 Colorado ST #9F, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 3292395)
$400,000
Lot Size
N/A

Home Size
637 sqft

Beds
1 Bed

Baths
1 Bath

44 East Ave #3806
Austin, TX
Photo of 44 East Ave #3806, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 1271873)
$799,000
Lot Size
N/A

Home Size
796 sqft

Beds
2 Beds

Baths
2 Baths

360 Nueces ST #1601
Austin, TX
Photo of 360 Nueces ST #1601, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 7663423)
$675,000
Lot Size
88 sqft

Home Size
801 sqft

Beds
1 Bed

Baths
1 Bath

  • 70 Rainey ST #3203
    Austin, TX
    Photo of 70 Rainey ST #3203, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 3273694)
    $5,150,000
    Lot Size
    N/A

    Home Size
    3,685 sqft

    Beds
    3 Beds

    Baths
    4 Baths

  • 360 Nueces ST #1318
    Austin, TX
    Photo of 360 Nueces ST #1318, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 1267741)
    $579,000
    Lot Size
    101 sqft

    Home Size
    760 sqft

    Beds
    1 Bed

    Baths
    1 Bath

  • 54 Rainey ST #910
    Austin, TX
    Photo of 54 Rainey ST #910, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 8511392)
    $535,000
    Lot Size
    192 sqft

    Home Size
    756 sqft

    Beds
    1 Bed

    Baths
    1 Bath

  • 84 East Ave #1509
    Austin, TX
    Photo of 84 East Ave #1509, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 1313525)
    $1,090,000
    Lot Size
    17,163 sqft

    Home Size
    1,176 sqft

    Beds
    2 Beds

    Baths
    2 Baths

  • 84 East Ave #2404
    Austin, TX
    Photo of 84 East Ave #2404, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 8487174)
    $838,000
    Lot Size
    17,154 sqft

    Home Size
    892 sqft

    Beds
    1 Bed

    Baths
    1 Bath

  • 1801 Lavaca ST #13G
    Austin, TX
    Photo of 1801 Lavaca ST #13G, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 3315746)
    $625,000
    Lot Size
    353 sqft

    Home Size
    1,377 sqft

    Beds
    2 Beds

    Baths
    2 Baths

  • 210 LAVACA St #2610
    Austin, TX
    Photo of 210 LAVACA St #2610, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 8572231)
    $2,995,000
    Lot Size
    6,321 sqft

    Home Size
    2,846 sqft

    Beds
    4 Beds

    Baths
    4 Baths

  • 48 East Ave #2004
    Austin, TX
    Photo of 48 East Ave #2004, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 3776814)
    $740,000
    Lot Size
    N/A

    Home Size
    893 sqft

    Beds
    1 Bed

    Baths
    1 Bath

  • 202 Nueces ST #2702
    Austin, TX
    Photo of 202 Nueces ST #2702, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 6197965)
    $4,500,000
    Lot Size
    N/A

    Home Size
    2,570 sqft

    Beds
    3 Beds

    Baths
    3.5 Baths

  • 360 Nueces ST #3006
    Austin, TX
    Photo of 360 Nueces ST #3006, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 2593926)
    $549,000
    Lot Size
    101 sqft

    Home Size
    748 sqft

    Beds
    1 Bed

    Baths
    1 Bath

  • 603 Davis ST #902
    Austin, TX
    Photo of 603 Davis ST #902, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 5767894)
    $799,000
    Lot Size
    301 sqft

    Home Size
    1,597 sqft

    Beds
    2 Beds

    Baths
    2 Baths

  • 601 E Brushy ST #204
    Austin, TX
    Photo of 601 E Brushy ST #204, Austin, TX 78702 (MLS # 8694737)
    $470,000
    Lot Size
    567 sqft

    Home Size
    701 sqft

    Beds
    1 Bed

    Baths
    1 Bath

  • 710 Colorado ST #9F
    Austin, TX
    Photo of 710 Colorado ST #9F, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 3292395)
    $400,000
    Lot Size
    N/A

    Home Size
    637 sqft

    Beds
    1 Bed

    Baths
    1 Bath

  • 44 East Ave #3806
    Austin, TX
    Photo of 44 East Ave #3806, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 1271873)
    $799,000
    Lot Size
    N/A

    Home Size
    796 sqft

    Beds
    2 Beds

    Baths
    2 Baths

  • 360 Nueces ST #1601
    Austin, TX
    Photo of 360 Nueces ST #1601, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 7663423)
    $675,000
    Lot Size
    88 sqft

    Home Size
    801 sqft

    Beds
    1 Bed

    Baths
    1 Bath

Previous Next
 

Editor's Suggested Posts

In 1986, an Architecture Critic Roasted Austin's 'Pompous' Skyline

In 1986, an Architecture Critic Roasted Austin's 'Pompous' Skyline

When the Klan Took Republic Square

When the Klan Took Republic Square

Take a Peek at Travis County's New Downtown Courthouse Design

Take a Peek at Travis County's New Downtown Courthouse Design

Related

Filed Under: News Tagged With: 78701, architecture, design

About James Rambin

James is an Austin native and fifth-generation Texan, but tries not to brag about it. Email him anything at james@towers.net.

360 Nueces ST #914
Austin, TX
Photo of 360 Nueces ST #914, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 2301936)
$640,000
40
  • Lot Size
    149 sqft

  • Home Size
    832 sqft

  • Beds
    1 Bed

  • Baths
    1 Bath

View Virtual Tour
Previous Post: « Let’s Have a Nice Day at Waterloo Park, (Finally) Set to Open This Fall
Next Post: The Independent’s Crown Officially Lights Up Tomorrow Night »

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

  •  Schedule a showing

FEATURED Listings

210 Lavaca ST #2312
Austin, TX
Photo of 210 Lavaca ST #2312, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 1330450)
$1,925,000
38
  • Lot Size
    131 sqft

  • Home Size
    1,587 sqft

  • Beds
    2 Beds

  • Baths
    2.5 Baths

313 W 17th ST #1307
Austin, TX
Photo of 313 W 17th ST #1307, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 4035178)
$1,750,000
9
  • Lot Size

  • Home Size
    1,930 sqft

  • Beds
    4 Beds

  • Baths
    3 Baths

360 Nueces ST #914
Austin, TX
Photo of 360 Nueces ST #914, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 2301936)
$640,000
40
  • Lot Size
    149 sqft

  • Home Size
    832 sqft

  • Beds
    1 Bed

  • Baths
    1 Bath

View Virtual Tour
48 East Ave #2407
Austin, TX
Photo of 48 East Ave #2407, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 8889100)
$590,000
33
  • Lot Size

  • Home Size
    699 sqft

  • Beds
    1 Bed

  • Baths
    1 Bath

555 E 5TH ST #2806
Austin, TX
Photo of 555 E 5TH ST #2806, Austin, TX 78701 (MLS # 1112164)
$775,000
33
  • Lot Size
    131 sqft

  • Home Size
    1,416 sqft

  • Beds
    2 Beds

  • Baths
    2 Baths

austin condo report

Featured Buildings

  • The Independent
  • Fifth & West
  • 360
  • Austin City Lofts
  • W Residences
  • The Shore
  • 70 Rainey

Footer

LEGAL NOTICE

TREC Information About Brokerage Services (pdf)

Texas Real Estate Commission Consumer Protection Notice


TOWERS realty

Austin Condos For Sale

Agents

Downtown Buildings

Luxury Towers

  • Four Seasons Residences
  • W Hotel & Residences
  • The Austonian
  • 5 Fifty Five at Hilton

Most Popular

  • The Shore
  • 360 Condos
  • Seaholm Condos
  • Spring Condos
  • Milago Condos

New Construction

  • The Independent
  • 70 Rainey
  • Austin Proper
  • Fifth & West

Loft Style

  • Austin City Lofts
  • Brazos Place
  • The Sabine
  • Plaza Lofts
  • Brown Building

Resources

  • Austin Condo Guide
  • Condos For Sale
  • Condo Buyer FAQ
  • Property Search

Featured

Archives

Newsletter · About · Contact Us · DMCA · Privacy Policy · SLAPP · Copyright © 2007-2022 TOWERS.net · All Rights Reserved
 

Loading Comments...